untitled
Published in The Heirloom Gardener, Spring 2004


Be It Ever So Humble

If there is a humble vegetable, it would have to be the cucumber (Cucurbitaceae Cucumis sativus).  No one waxes poetic about cucumbers.  There are no recipes showcasing the cucumber.  No stuffed cucumbers, cucumber pie or cucumber souffle.  It has been elevated somewhat facetiously by the haughty cucumber sandwich, but for the most part this vegetable is just an after thought, pickled and garnishing your hamburger.

Not true at Duris Cucumber Farm in Puyallup, WA.  Forty-six years ago Mrs. Duris, alarmed at the cost of cucumbers in the local stores, talked her husband into planting a third of an acre of his small farm in cucumbers.  She planned to sell them by the side of the road and pay back all the costs of growing.  Mrs. Duris succeeded and then some.  That first year she recouped her costs and bought herself a new sewing machine.  And the Duris Cucumber Farm went into business.  Sondra Duris Andrews is still manning the vegetable stand and, although they began adding a new vegetable to their offerings each year, she says it is the cucumbers people come back for.  Not the burpless varieties or the exotic Asian types.  The humble pickler and slicer.

So maybe we should take a second look and show this lowly vegetable a bit more respect.  They are easy to grow.  They are so prolific in production we don’t know what to do with the bounty.  Their cool savoriness absolutely evokes summer.   All good things.  However no matter how many varieties you try, they all taste pretty much the same.  Or do they?    


Cucumber Smorgasbord

Sad to say, most Americans have probably never tasted a real cucumber, fresh and juicy from the vine with no waxy coating to protect it.  American cucs, like our tomatoes, have been bred to ship and store well, at the expense of flavor.  They are basically water and crunch with the main distinction being between the two categories, slicing and pickling.  In fact, there is a fair amount of diversity in the cucumber world.       

The originals are believed to be descended from wild Cucurbita found in the Himalayas.  Today’s Oriental cucumbers come in a range of colors, lengths and flavors, but most are long, thin-skinned and slender.  They also tend to be warted or spined, but brushing off the spines is enough to make them edible without peeling.  Rather than a sweet taste, they offer a fresh, rich juiciness.  ‘Suyo Long’ offers high yields of fruits that are almost seedless.  They are also crisp and never bitter.   ‘Mideast Prolific’ is great fresh or pickled.  They only get about 5-7 inches long and remain thin-skinned.  They are also early, productive, adaptable and delicious.

Developed in Israel, Middle Eastern cucumbers, also called Beit Alpha types, resemble a small version of the European greenhouse cucumber becoming popular in American groceries, but these can be grown in the field.  Like greenhouse cucumbers they are parthenocarpic, meaning they don’t require pollination. Middle Eastern cucs give a strong blast of the flavor we’ve come to associate with cucumbers.  “Amira” is gaining popularity in southern areas.

Harder to find, the Armenian cucumber or snake melon (Cucumis melo) is mild and slightly citric and sweet in flavor.  These are long, slender fruits that are almost always curved or snaked, with pale furrows running lengthwise in the skin.  The fruits can grow 2-3 feet long, but taste best at 12-15 inches.  This type is a good choice for hot climates.  However while they look and taste like cucumbers, they are actually a type of melon and will cross pollinate with other melons.  You can occasionally find these varieties in Middle Eastern groceries.   You can also find seeds under names like ‘China Long’ and  ‘Armenian Yard Long’.  Oriental, Middle Eastern and Armenian cucs can stand up to light sauteeing and therefore find their way into more dishes than just the salad.

The ‘West Indian Gherkin’ (Cucumis anguria) arrived in America from Jamaica, although it probably originated in Africa.  This also is not a sativus, even though it shares some similar qualities.  The gherkin has vigorous vines with smooth leaves like a watermelon.  The fruits are 2-3  long, plump and  oval with a distinctive taste.  The immature fruits are used for pickling. The glossy, pale green skins are covered in burr like spines when they mature.

If Americans are familiar with an exotic cucumber it is probably the hothouse type known as European or Dutch greenhouse cucumbers.  These are the long, dark, smooth specimens that are usually sold in plastic wrap to protect their skins.  Greenhouse varieties were developed because many countries in Europe did not have the climate to support a field grown crop.  Many people prefer this type because they are virtually seedless, require no peeling and are considered easier to digest.  “Telegraph Improved” is a popular variety that is absolutely never bitter.   ‘Holland European’ is an improved greenhouse variety that can be grown outdoors.  However even in Europe preferences vary.  The French are partial to the tiny cornichon, used for pickling.  ‘Vert de Massy’, a variety from the 1800s, is still popular today.              

In America, the 8-inch slicer reigns supreme, although the popularity of pickles and relishes shouldn’t be underestimated .  The term pickler is somewhat misleading, as any type of cucumber can be used for slicing and eating fresh.  In fact, pickling cucumbers have not been as tampered with by hybridizers and are becoming more and more popular for slicing.  Andrews explained that pickling varieties have a thinner skin than slicers, allowing the brine to soak through.  They also have a dryer, denser texture that holds up during processing.

There is no shortage of great pickling type cucumbers.  ‘Boston Pickling’ dates back to 1880.   These vigorous vines produce a symmetrical and smooth fruit with crisp but dry flesh, perfect for processing. ‘Chicago Pickling’ is a longer pickler, at 6-7 inches, but it is thin skinned, a high yielder and disease resistant.   For those of us with short growing seasons, always look to eastern Europe.  ‘Early Russian’ starts producing early and just keeps going.  Another good Russian variety is ‘Parade”, with a heavy set of fruit maturing at one time, making it ideal for processing.  And it’s resistant to weather extremes.  

Despite the hybridizing that has been taking place in the world of slicing cucumbers, ‘Boothby’s Blonde’ has been grown for generations.  It is indeed a blonde cucumber, albeit warty with black spines.  Don’t let that stop you, as these spines also rub off and there’s no need to peel.

Another interesting heirloom enjoying renewed popularity is the ‘Lemon’ or ‘Lemon Apple’ cucumber.  The name refers to the fruits appearance, not the taste.  The exterior resembles a lemon and when sliced through, the seeds are in chambers resembling a citrus fruit.  If allowed to grow large, the seeds become excessive.  But scooping out the seeds gives you an edible bowl perfect for serving your favorite seafood salad.  ‘Lemon’ cucs are rust and drought tolerant.

So why aren’t cucumbers better respected in America?  Part of the blame can be attributed to the sometimes bitter taste of cucumbers.  Bitterness is caused by compounds called cucurbitacins, which are genetic and passed down through seeds.  The concentration of cucurbitacins is often greater at the ends of the cucumber and discarding these parts will help some in reducing the bitter taste. You can draw out the bitterness in the rest of the cucumber by osmosis - slice, salt, drain and rinse, before using.

Then there’s the waxy coating on most commercial  cucumbers, put on to preserve moisture.  It is best to remove the waxed skin before eating.  Local and organically grown cucs don’t need this protection and are a better choice if you prefer to leave the skin on.

Growing

The most difficult aspect to successfully growing cucumbers is insuring adequate pollination.   Most heirloom varieties and many current cucumber cultivars are monoecious, meaning they  produce separate staminate (male) and pistillate (female) flowers on the same plant.  They tend to begin producing all male flowers first, often frustrating home gardeners who see flowers but no fruit.

Many hybrids have been bred to be gynoecious, meaning they produce mostly female flowers.  This encourages earlier and greater productivity.  Even so, the production of more male flowers can result from long day lengths and high temperatures or when the plant becomes stressed from a large fruit set.  Either way, cucumber flowers require 10-20 bee visits for proper pollination and each flower is only open for one day.  Without multiple pollination visits, the fruits can be malformed or tiny.  

Cucumber plants bear over an extended period, maturing at different times depending on when they are pollinated.  This means harvesting may have to be done everyday.  The ideal size for slicers is from 1 1/4 to 2  in diameter and 6-8  long, for best taste and texture.

When saving seeds from cucumbers, remember that all sativus will cross pollinate with one another, but not with other cucurbits.  Sativus varieties need to be isolated by ½ mile.


Pests

The second greatest obstacle to a successful cucumber harvest is the fact that they are pest magnets.  Cucumber beetles, squash bugs and squash vine borers will inevitably find their way to your cucumber patch.  Cucumber beetles often leave behind a disease or two like wilt or cucumber mosaic.  Then there’s downy mildew, powdery mildew, anthracnose, angular leaf spot and scab.  

Studies have shown that cucumber pest problems are often the result of poor soil or imbalanced fertilization, particularly excess nitrogen and/or limited trace elements.  You can also boost your success rate by planting resistant varieties, rotating crops and removing debris in the fall.

Since many cucumber diseases are spread by insects, managing the insect pests can often ward off disease.  If you do find yourself with problems, be cautious with pesticides. Cucumber leaves can be easily damaged by insecticidal soaps and copper sprays.  When all else fails, try interplanting with onions.  The verdict is still out on this one, but apparently scent confuses insects and like the rest of us, they have their likes and dislikes.    


To Market

If you plan on growing cucumbers for the farm market, taste and novelty are what sells, as long as they are not so novel that the customer won’t know what to do with them.  Here your best bet is a something resembling the thin skinned European varieties.  Another selling feature of locally grown cucumbers is their lack of a waxy coating, particularly if they are organically grown.  Of course, the Duris family farm has built a business around the basic pickler cucumber.

Refrigerating immediately after harvest cools the fruits and extends their shelf like.  According to the Penn. State Extension Service, cucs kept at 50-55o F and 95% humidity can retain their quality for 10 - 14 days.   Better still, try some cold cucumber soup, cucumber salsa or stir fried cucumber and snow peas.  Or try one of the recipes in the sidebar.

Return to Home Page

Report Content · · Web Hosting · Blog · Guestbooks · Message Forums · Mailing Lists
Easiest Website Builder ever! · Build your own toolbar · Free Talking Character · Email Marketing
powered by a free webtools company bravenet.com